Starting this blog, I decided I wanted to use a 10 point rubric per category to evaluate figures.
So far, the system is...ok. Any of these systems ultimately has bias and isn't exact, however, I'll break down the system but I think a revamp soon is in order. Perhaps adding in a fun factor to the assessment? There is a certain quality that makes a figure fun to pose and play with regardless of how poor or good the paint, sculpt, accessories, and occasionally even the articulation. This will require further thought.
Sculpting
and Paint: 1 = No, or little paint anywhere, minimal sculpting. Basic body form only.
2 = No, or little paint, A little sculpting with some stylistic additions.
3= Some paint application, but no shading. Some sculpting.
4= Some paint application, some shading, some sculpted parts.
5= Good paint application, some shading, some sculpted parts.
6= Good paint application, good shading, some sculpted parts
7 =Good paint, good shading, good sculpting.
8=Excellent paint, good use of shading, excellent sculpted parts
9=Excellent and thorough paint work, excellent shades applied, excellent sculpted parts.
10=One of the best designed figures: either perfectly stylistic to the character or perfectly realistic to the original source material (game, comic, tv, etc)
Articulation: 1 = 5 or fewer points of articulation. Imaginex comes to mind or other childrens toys.
2 = 6-10points of articulation. No waist swivels, ankle joints, elbow joints (Old He- man toys)
3= 11-15 points of articulation. No waist swivel, ankle joints. Poor design.
4= 16-20 points of articulation. No ab crunch, ankle joints. Elbow/knee joints do have 90 degree flexion. No split capability with legs. Hand and/or boot cut swivel.
5= 16-20 points of articulation. Elbows/knees have 90 degree flexion. Forward/backward ankle flexion. May have ab crunch and swivel.
6= 16-20 points of articulation. Ab crunch present, may have diaphragm joint.
7= 21-25 points of articulation. Double jointed knees and/or elbows present. Ankle rocker. Two point wrist articulation (Basic Marvel Legends).
8= 25-35 points of articulation. All the above plus diaphragm joints, butterfly shoulder joints. May include toe swivel or finger articulation. (S.H. Figuarts figures). Design may limit some articulation.
9 = 35+ points of articulation. Includes all the above plus sculpted parts that can move (capes, wings, holsters etc). Excellent design that does not limit movement.
10 = An insane amount of articulation. You can pose this figure anyway, anywhere!
Price point/availability: After all, what's the point if you can't find or buy it reasonably?
1= You will never find this figure and/or buy this figure. It isn't being made, and if i was sold, you'd need a trust fund to afford it.
2= Few available, price is at 500% mark up.
3= Few available, price is at 200-400% mark up.
4= Few available, price is at 100-200%
5=Available online mostly. price is at 100% mark up.
6=Available online and some in stores. Price is at a 50-100% mark up.
7=Readily available in stores and online. Price is at original/current value.
8=Readily available online and in stores. Discounted 15% or less.
9= Readily available online and in stores. Discounted 30-50%.
10=Readily available online and in stores. Discounted 50%+. Buy all the things!
Accessories: 0= No accessories. Boo!
1= 1 accessory. Poorly painted/sculpted. Not accurate in size or design.
2 = 1 accesory. Some paint, decent design. Approximates source material.
3 = 1-3 accessories. Some paint, decent design, approximates source material.
4 = 1-3 accessories. Good paint and/or design, but not both. Few inaccuracies.
5 = 2+ accessories. One set of extra hands, or 2+ very well designed weapons/pieces.
6 = 2-5 accessories. Set of hands, and well sculpted weapons/pieces.
7 = 2 or more sets of extra hands and 1-3 weapons/pieces. Interchangeable body pieces.
8 = More than 2 sets of extra hands, weapons/pieces, interchangeable heads/faces.
9 = 4+ sets of hands, tons of hand held/body pieces, interchangeable heads/body pieces.
10 = Everything you could want given the source. Deluxe sets, etc.
Note: This system is amenable to modification at any time! I will post a footnote update should it change. Not yet satisfied with it.